What 300,000 tired people were actually diagnosed with

And why no single condition explains most of it.

Last week I wrote about men not going to the doctor, and I said the thing that stops them is not having anything tangible to take in. Saying “I am tired” does not feel like that concrete reason. There may well be a societal or cultural reason too, a stigma about not being able to stay energised and focused throughout the day, a demanding job but still needing the energy to go for a workout at lunch or after work. The pressure to keep up with social media will also have a part to play, making us, not just men, feel like we are lagging behind and we should be able to keep up.
But what happens to the people who do go to their GP?
I expected a list of missed conditions; thyroid, iron, B12, the usual suspects, or at least a more direct outcome of what patients went in for. After all, we have so much information at our fingertips that we should be able to whittle most symptoms down to a couple of possible conditions. But that is not what I found, and it surprised me.
First, you are not unusual
Tiredness is the main reason for roughly one in fifteen GP appointments. That means two or three people, every single day, coming through the door because they are tired.
I want to call this out because a lot of people sit on it for months, convinced they are being dramatic or will be wasting somebody’s time. You are most definitely not. Tiredness is one of the most common reasons people seek help from their GP and it's a perfectly valid reason to make an appointment.
What the researchers did
In December 2024 researchers at UCL published a study in the British Journal of General Practice (BJGP). The study took a four-stage approach:
Took 304,914 people in England who went to their GP with new tiredness between 2007 and 2017.
Used anonymised primary care records linked to hospital data and the national cancer registry.
Compared them against two separate groups: 423,671 people who visited their GP for a different reason, and a further 759,904 registered patients.
Finally, they tracked 237 separate diseases and worked out what each group was diagnosed with over the following twelve months.
This wasn’t a survey, nor a questionnaire. It was based on actual diagnoses, recorded at the time, from approximately 300,000 people.
Who was in it, which is interesting before you even get to the findings
Of the people who presented with fatigue, 100,881 were men and 204,033 were women. That’s twice as many women. Hold up before you assume the study simply had more women in it, because their comparison population was almost exactly balanced, 375,799 men against 384,105 women.
I cannot tell you why there is such a big gap and neither could the study. But it is the same gap I wrote about last week from a 2013 paper, turning up again in a completely different dataset eleven years later, in a study that was not looking for it.
What they found
The percentages below are of those who went in tired, against those who went in for something else.
Men
Diagnosis | Went in tired | Did not | Rank |
Depression | 3.21% | 0.83% | 1st |
All cancers | 2.59% | 1.16% | 7th |
Other anaemias | 1.68% | 0.43% | 9th |
Women
Diagnosis | Went in tired | Did not | Rank |
Depression | 3.64% | 1.28% | 1st |
Thyroid (hyper or hypo) | 2.43% | 0.67% | 4th |
Iron deficiency anaemia | 1.48% | 0.42% | 9th |
All cancers | 1.42% | 0.90% | 21st |
The bit that caught me off guard
Depression. First, in both men and women, by a long way. Not thyroid, iron, or vitamin D, which is where most of the internet would point you to.
I want to be careful here, because this is the boundaries of my work. I am a nutritional therapist and do not assess or treat depression. What I can do is tell you what the largest UK study of this question found, so if this is something that needs further discussion, your GP is the person to talk to.
Nutritional therapists work closely with GPs and most of us have a multi-disciplinary team in our network. We are clear on the guidelines for referral, and on signposting anything that falls into the medical arena rather than ours. We take that part very seriously and it forms part of our industry body’s rules and guidelines. I think it is one of the most useful things I can tell you.
The percentages I keep going back to
The top condition accounts for about three men in a hundred. Cancer, two and a half. Anaemia, under two. And it drops fast, beyond the top ten conditions the excess risk drops below one per cent. Of the 237 diseases they tracked, 98 in men had fewer than a hundred people diagnosed at all, and were dropped from the analysis.
So no single thing explains most tiredness. The diagnoses are spread thin, and I would argue that is a more interesting finding than a tidy list of missed conditions would have been.
Which does not mean nothing is wrong
This is the part I feel people get wrong in both directions.
One camp hears “no diagnosis” and concludes it is in your head. The other hears it and goes hunting for a hidden disease that nobody has found yet.
I think both are wrong. If the common pathologies have been excluded, that is a genuinely useful result, because it tells you where the answer is not. And what is left is not mysterious and shows us that the foundational pillars of health need looking at more closely. Is how much you are eating matching how much you are doing? How much alcohol do you drink in an average week? What is your training load? What are your social networks like? When did you last take a walk in nature? None of that is a disease and none show up on a blood panel. It is also, in my experience, where almost all of it tracks back to.
Where I would stop and send you elsewhere
Some tiredness is not a pattern and needs looking at properly. Unexplained weight loss, fever, night sweats, swollen glands that do not go down, unexplained bleeding. Any of those alongside fatigue is a GP appointment ASAP, not a nutrition conversation.
And the study is specific on one point. The authors concluded that their findings support prioritising cancer investigation in men aged 70 and over who present with fatigue, though not in women at any age on the basis of fatigue alone.
If you are a man over 70 and you have been tired for months, please go and see your GP.
So should you get bloods done?
I have always said that one of the most useful things to do is get something measured and know where you are.
A blood panel will probably not find you a definite answer. But what it will do is rule out the handful of things that genuinely need ruling out, mainly disease and deficiency, and start giving you clues. That is absolutely worth knowing, but it is not the same as being told what is wrong.
I had a client this year whose continuous glucose data was excellent. She logged an afternoon slump, and her glucose at that exact moment was completely flat. The most useful thing that fortnight of data did was prove what the problem was not. That is exactly what testing is for, as much to rule things out as to find them. Anybody selling it to you as a diagnosis machine is overpromising.
What I take from it
Most tiredness is not a diagnosis waiting to be found. It is a pattern, and I would put money that nobody is looking at it to help you join the dots.
The pattern tends to be boring and unglamorous, because it is the fundamentals of a healthy lifestyle. Mostly it's some combination of not sleeping enough, not eating enough for what you are doing, and not recovering adequately. There is no test for that, it requires somebody sitting down with you and going through it properly.
That is the work. It is less exciting than discovering a thyroid problem, but it's far more likely to be the answer.
Reference:
White B, Renzi C, Rafiq M, et al. Underlying disease risk among patients with fatigue: a population-based cohort study in primary care. British Journal of General Practice 2024 Dec 10;75(750):e57–e67. doi:10.3399/BJGP.2024.0093





Comments