The land owns them

I have been doing this puzzle....

... no ordinary one.
Not an ordinary one. My dad brought it over from Egypt, hoping we would do it together. We never did, though not for want of wanting to. This year we talked more than we ever have, and I am grateful for that instead.
Credit to my dad, it was one of his best gifts. Made by a small company in Egypt from eco-friendly materials, promoting “creativity with brain training fun”. It is Nefertiti, of course, and the whole thing is cut to her shape, the headdress and the face and that enormous collar. Every single piece is a little figure in its own right. Birds, a tomb, an ankh, a camel. Shapes I had to turn over twice before I could work out what they were meant to be.
I sat there building a queen out of symbols, one symbol at a time. And while I was doing it, scrolling for something to listen to, a podcast title caught my eye. The Origin of Symbolism.
It was as if the universe had turned and looked at me for a split second. As though sitting there with symbols in my hands had been enough to catch its attention, and for it to send me exactly what I needed to hear.
The word that got me
The guest was Genevieve von Petzinger, which I agree with the host Cory Allen is one of the best names I have heard in a long time. She is a palaeoanthropologist who studies the geometric signs painted on cave walls in Europe tens of thousands of years ago. But not the famous animals we would imagine. She studies the dots, the lines, the little repeated marks that sit alongside them. The parts nobody seems to study, and the parts Genevieve thinks may be the beginning of us recording anything at all.
Then, about fifteen minutes in, she used a word I had never heard.
Presentism.
It is what researchers in her field have to watch for constantly. She described it as accidentally bringing your own reality with you when you go and study people who may not have organised themselves, or thought, anything like you do.
You look at a cave painting and you see art, because we have a category called art. They may not have had such a category. You look for evidence of religion, because we keep religion in one part of life and the washing up in another. They may not have separated anything. She thinks they probably had no line between the two at all, that it was one continuous thing.
Progress on the puzzle slowed right down.
We do this with food constantly
You have heard the advice. Eat like your grandparents. Eat like a hunter gatherer. If your great grandmother would not recognise it as food, she wouldn't eat it and nor should you. I understand where it comes from, and most of it is sensible. But now I can name the little itch I feel when I hear it. It is presentism.
Start with the obvious problem. Which ancestors? The Inuit and the Hadza and the Tsimané ate almost nothing in common. Whose grandparents, for that matter? A British kitchen in the 1950s meant rationing, lard, white bread and virtually no vegetables between November and April. That's somebody’s grandmother and nobody is recommending it.
Then the part that gets breezed over. The food itself has changed, bred and grown and stored differently. Movement was not scheduled in the day; it was the day. Light and sleep were not managed, they just happened. There was real scarcity and real seasonality, and nobody is replicating those. And a great many of them did not live long enough to develop the conditions we are trying to prevent.
But here is the bit I had not seen before
The deepest problem with eating like your ancestors is not that we cannot know what they ate, it's that the advice is compartmentalised, and they were not.
It looks back into the archives, takes the food, and hands you that part on its own. But the food was never a separate thing. It came with the walking, daylight, sleeping when it got dark, and real scarcity, and the fact that getting food and not being food dedicated most of your day.
You can copy the food, but it's pretty hard to copy any of the rest of it.
And then she said something that stopped the puzzle completely
Talking about modern hunter gatherer groups, she put it like this. “They feel more like the land owns them.” That they come from it, that they will return to it, and that the ownership runs the opposite way to the one we assume today.
Somewhere along the line I feel we have turned that around.
I wrote last year about where my meat comes from, and about Knepp Farm, and the reason that piece mattered to me was not really about farming. It was that most of us eat three or four times a day and rarely think about the place any of it came from. That is the same separation, just further upstream.
I am not going to tell you they were wiser than us
Von Petzinger catches herself at it constantly. She watches for it in her own work, which is the part I loved about her and her work. She describes the caves she has spent 300 hours inside. To us they feel dark, separate and strange, with a mysticism about them, which is itself our reality laid over something that may have been nothing of the sort.
She also describes hunter gatherers as intensely practical and down to earth, because they had to be. Life was short, hard and a great deal of it was about not dying.
Romanticising them is the same mistake pointing the other way. Either way it is my world I am seeing, not theirs. And probably with better lighting.
So what actually survives the translation
Not a food list. What survives is the shape of it. Food that is close to how it grew. Plenty of fibre and plenty of variety, because monotony is a modern luxury. Eating in some kind of rhythm rather than continuously. Movement that is part of the day rather than an appointment. And knowing where at least some of it came from. A farm, a market, a name. It does not have to be everything.
None of that is worth doing because it is ancient. It is worth doing because it has been tested in people who are alive now, and it stands up.
And that distinction matters to me. Believe something because it is ancestral and you are stuck with all of it, including the parts that turn out not to be true. Believe it because of what the evidence shows and you can let those parts go without losing the rest.
The puzzle
I finished it, eventually.
And the thing about a puzzle made of symbols is that every piece means something on its own, and none of them mean very much until they are next to the others. A bird is a bird. Put four hundred of them together and you have a queen.
Which is, more or less, the whole of my job.
Genevieve von Petzinger was speaking on And Then It Hit Me with Cory Allen, episode 109, The Origin of Symbolism.





Comments